Absolutely Charming & Fabulous
The other night was the kind of night where only some serious comfort
food could make things right. It was the kind of night where pot roast seemed
to make perfect sense. I knew I would need to flip through one of my classic
books to find just the right recipe and guess what I discovered… that I have a
new favorite cook book. I do! Really! It’s the Fireside Cookbook by James
Beard, the 1949 edition with illustrations from Alice and Martin Provensen.
It’s so unbelievably charming.
What does it have to say about pot roast? That, “It is
hearty fare and one that is relished by all who are blessed with good
appetites.” Good appetite? Check. And a need for a drink? Double check. Luckily
Mr. Beard offers several variation of pot roast… Plain, Italian Style, With Wine and
Hungarian. “With Wine” it is!
How could this duo not induce glee?
Confession time… this was my first pot roast. Ever. It was!
And it came out perfectly. Tender, rich, comforting and even better the next
day. I used a Le Creuset Dutch Oven, which I’m totally convinced let to the
tenderness.
This is the recipe as it is written on page 107 with my
changes in italics:
“Choose a 4 to 6 pound pot roast. Wipe it with a damp cloth
and season with salt and pepper. Lard
the meat well with ¼ inch strips of salt pork. I didn’t happen to have salt pork so I gave it an olive oil rub down. Sear
in 4 tbs butter until nicely browned on all sides. Pour over 6 tbs cognac and
blaze. No cognac so I skipped this step.
Extinguish the flame and add 1 clove garlic, I added 4, 1 bay leaf, and a pinch of thyme, and 2 cups red or
white wine I used a cabernet. Cover
and simmer for about 25 minutes per pound or until tender. Add 12 small white
onions, peeled, and 4 or 5 carrots, peeled and cut in strips. I also added mushrooms, celery and fingerling
potatoes. If you need additional liquid, add another ½ cup wine. I added the wine and 1 cup of tomato puree.
Continue simmering until the meat and vegetables are tender. Just before
serving, add ¼ cup finely chopped parsley and stir it into the sauce. Arrange
vegetables around the meat on a hot platter and pour the sauce over. Buttered
noodles or potatoes mashed with butter and cream are excellent with this.”

If you’ve been intimidated by the big hunk of meat that is
pot roast definitely give this a try. The butter searing, the rich sauce, the
leftovers…. it’s undeniably worth a try.
Enjoy!
EB